When your water heater fails to ignite, it can quickly disrupt your daily routine with cold showers and inability to perform regular household tasks. This common problem affects both gas and electric water heaters, though the causes and solutions differ significantly between types.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the most common reasons for ignition failure, provide step-by-step troubleshooting methods, and offer practical solutions to get your hot water flowing again. While some fixes are simple enough for DIY repairs, others require professional intervention for safety and effectiveness.
| Common Causes | Potential Solutions | DIY or Professional |
|---|---|---|
| Pilot light out | Relight following manufacturer instructions | DIY |
| Faulty thermocouple | Clean or replace thermocouple | DIY/Professional |
| Gas supply issues | Check gas valve and supply | DIY |
| Control valve malfunction | Repair or replace valve | Professional |
| Electrical problems | Check circuit breakers and elements | DIY/Professional |
Understanding why your water heater won’t ignite is the first step toward resolving the issue. Gas and electric water heaters have different ignition systems, but both can fail for several reasons. For gas models, the most frequent culprits include pilot light problems, thermocouple failures, gas supply interruptions, and control valve malfunctions.
Electric water heaters typically face issues with faulty heating elements, thermostat problems, tripped circuit breakers, or burnt-out components. Environmental factors like insufficient ventilation, dust accumulation, or moisture can affect both types. Age-related wear and poor maintenance significantly increase the likelihood of ignition problems, with most water heaters developing issues after 8-12 years of service.
Gas Supply Issues
A common reason gas water heaters fail to ignite is interrupted gas flow. This can occur when the gas valve is partially or completely closed, gas payments are overdue leading to service disconnection, or there’s a gas line obstruction. Sometimes, the problem is as simple as the gas control knob being set to the wrong position.
Natural gas outages in your area can also prevent ignition. To check if gas is flowing to your water heater, verify that other gas appliances in your home are working properly. If multiple gas appliances are non-functional, the issue likely lies with your main gas supply rather than the water heater itself.
Thermocouple Problems
The thermocouple is a safety device that senses when the pilot light is lit and allows gas to flow to the main burner. When it malfunctions, the gas supply automatically shuts off to prevent dangerous gas accumulation. Dirty, bent, or worn thermocouples are common culprits when water heaters won’t ignite.
Over time, thermocouples can become coated with carbon deposits that interfere with proper function. They can also wear out naturally after years of use. A properly functioning thermocouple should generate about 25-30 millivolts when heated by the pilot flame. Less voltage indicates it needs cleaning or replacement, a relatively inexpensive repair that can often be handled by homeowners with basic tools.
Pilot Light Failures
The pilot light serves as the ignition source for the main burner in gas water heaters. When it goes out, your water heater cannot produce hot water. Pilot lights can extinguish due to drafts, dirt accumulation, or gas supply interruptions. In newer models with electronic ignition, the igniter itself may fail or become coated with debris.
Some water heaters have a small viewing window where you can check if the pilot light is on. A healthy pilot flame should be primarily blue with minimal yellow coloring. A yellow flame indicates incomplete combustion, often due to dirty components or poor ventilation, which can prevent proper ignition of the main burner even when the pilot is lit.
Control Valve Malfunctions
The gas control valve regulates gas flow to both the pilot light and main burner. It contains multiple components including thermostats, safety devices, and the actual valve mechanism. When any part of this assembly fails, your water heater may not ignite. Control valve problems are among the most complex water heater issues to diagnose and repair.
Common symptoms of control valve problems include difficulty keeping the pilot lit, inconsistent heating, or complete failure to ignite. Control valves typically last the lifetime of the water heater but can fail prematurely due to sediment buildup, power surges (in electronic models), or physical damage. Replacement usually requires professional expertise and represents a significant repair cost.
Electrical Issues (For Electric Water Heaters)
Electric water heaters don’t have pilot lights but can still fail to “ignite” or heat water due to electrical problems. Tripped circuit breakers, blown fuses, or power outages are obvious causes to check first. More complex issues include faulty heating elements, broken thermostats, or wiring problems within the unit.
Some electric models have a high-temperature cutoff switch that trips when the water gets too hot, preventing the heating elements from activating until manually reset. Additionally, electric water heaters typically have two heating elements – if one fails, you may experience reduced hot water capacity rather than complete failure, making the problem less immediately noticeable.
Diagnosing a Water Heater That Won’t Ignite
Before attempting any repairs, proper diagnosis is essential to avoid wasting time and money on unnecessary parts or procedures. This systematic approach will help identify the specific issue with your water heater. Safety should always be your primary concern when working with gas appliances or electrical components.
Safety Precautions Before You Begin
Water heater troubleshooting involves potential exposure to gas, electricity, and hot surfaces, all of which present safety hazards. Before starting, turn off the gas supply or power to the water heater. For gas models, locate the dedicated shutoff valve on the gas line near the unit and turn it perpendicular to the pipe. For electric models, switch off the corresponding circuit breaker.
Ensure the area is well-ventilated, especially when working with gas appliances. Have a flashlight ready for better visibility of internal components. Never force any parts that don’t move easily, as this could damage the water heater or create dangerous gas leaks. If you detect a strong gas odor at any point, leave the house immediately and call your gas provider from a safe location.
Checking the Gas Supply
For gas water heaters, verify that gas is flowing to your unit. Check that the gas valve near the water heater is in the open position (handle parallel to the gas line). Next, confirm that other gas appliances in your home are functioning, which indicates the main gas supply is active. Listen for hissing sounds when attempting to light the pilot, which would indicate gas is flowing to the pilot assembly.
If you’ve recently had gas service work or if your home was vacant for a period, air may be present in the gas lines. In such cases, it might take several attempts to purge the air and establish a consistent gas flow. If you’ve verified gas is available and flowing to other appliances but not reaching your water heater, there may be an obstruction in the line or a problem with the water heater’s internal gas valve.
Inspecting the Pilot Light
For water heaters with conventional pilot lights, remove the access panel and burner cover to view the pilot assembly. Use a flashlight to check if the pilot is lit – you should see a small blue flame. If it’s out, follow the manufacturer’s instructions to relight it, typically found on a label on the water heater. Observe if the pilot stays lit after you release the reset button or gas control knob.
If the pilot won’t light or won’t stay lit, examine the pilot tube for obstructions. A partially blocked pilot tube can result in a weak flame that’s easily extinguished or insufficient to heat the thermocouple properly. In models with electronic ignition, listen for clicking sounds indicating the igniter is attempting to spark, and look for a brief flash or glow from the ignition element.
Testing the Thermocouple
The thermocouple appears as a copper tube positioned near the pilot flame. To test it, light the pilot following the manufacturer’s instructions while pressing the reset button or keeping the gas control knob depressed. Hold the button for at least 30 seconds to allow the thermocouple to heat up sufficiently. Release the button slowly – if the pilot immediately goes out, the thermocouple is likely faulty.
Visual inspection can also help diagnose thermocouple issues. Look for corrosion, bending, or damage. Ensure the thermocouple is properly positioned within the pilot flame – it should be partially immersed in the flame but not directly in the center. If the thermocouple appears dirty, gently clean it with fine emery cloth while being careful not to damage or bend it.
Examining the Control Valve
The gas control valve is a complex component that controls gas flow based on thermostat settings and safety inputs. Check that the control knob moves freely between settings (Off, Pilot, On) without sticking. Look for any signs of damage, corrosion, or water leakage around the valve body. Water leaking onto the control valve can cause internal corrosion and malfunction.
For water heaters with digital displays, check for error codes that might indicate specific control valve problems. Common error codes include those for flame failure, gas valve failure, or thermostat issues. If your water heater’s pilot stays lit but the main burner never ignites, the problem likely lies with the control valve’s thermostat function or the gas valve portion of the assembly.
Step-by-Step Guide to Fix a Gas Water Heater That Won’t Ignite
With a proper diagnosis in hand, you can proceed to fix many common ignition problems. This section provides detailed instructions for repairs that many homeowners can safely perform. Always follow manufacturers’ guidelines and don’t hesitate to call a professional if you’re uncertain about any repair procedure.
Relighting the Pilot Light
Often, the simplest solution is relighting an extinguished pilot light. Start by turning the gas control valve to the “Off” position and wait 5-10 minutes for any gas to dissipate. Set the temperature dial to its lowest setting and turn the control knob to “Pilot.” Press and hold down the reset button while bringing a long lighter or match to the pilot opening.
Once the pilot lights, continue holding the reset button for 30-60 seconds before releasing it slowly. If the pilot stays lit, replace the burner access panel, turn the gas control valve to “On,” and adjust the temperature setting as desired. If the pilot won’t light after several attempts or won’t stay lit after releasing the reset button, further troubleshooting is needed.
- Turn gas control knob to “Off”
- Wait 5-10 minutes
- Turn knob to “Pilot”
- Press and hold reset button
- Light pilot with long lighter or match
- Continue holding reset button 30-60 seconds
- Release button slowly
- If pilot stays lit, turn knob to “On”
Cleaning or Replacing the Thermocouple
If the pilot light won’t stay lit, a dirty or faulty thermocouple is likely the culprit. To clean the thermocouple, first shut off the gas supply and ensure the unit is cool. Remove the access panel and locate the thermocouple – the copper rod near the pilot tube. Gently clean the thermocouple with fine-grit sandpaper or emery cloth, focusing on the tip that’s exposed to the pilot flame.
If cleaning doesn’t resolve the issue, replacement is necessary. Thermocouples are inexpensive and widely available at hardware stores. To replace it, disconnect the thermocouple from the gas control valve (usually secured by a threaded fitting or clip), remove any brackets holding it in place, and extract the old thermocouple. Install the new one in the same position, ensuring the tip is properly positioned in the pilot flame area, and reconnect it to the gas control valve.
Addressing Gas Supply Problems
If gas supply issues are preventing ignition, first verify that the gas valve near the water heater is fully open. The handle should be parallel to the gas line, not perpendicular. If other gas appliances are also not working, check your gas meter to ensure service hasn’t been interrupted. Some gas meters have visible indicators showing whether gas is flowing.
For water heaters that haven’t been used for some time, air in the gas lines may prevent proper ignition. Attempting to light the pilot several times can help purge this air. If your gas supply uses propane from a tank rather than natural gas, check the tank’s fuel level. Low propane levels can cause insufficient pressure for proper water heater operation, especially during periods of high demand from multiple appliances.
Fixing Ventilation Issues
Poor ventilation can cause a water heater to shut down due to safety features that detect improper combustion. Inspect the draft hood at the top of the water heater and the vent pipe leading to the outside. Clear any obstructions like bird nests, debris, or dust that might block proper airflow. Ensure the vent pipe has proper slope (upward toward the outside) and doesn’t have any dents or crimps.
In homes with negative air pressure issues, outside air may be pulled down the vent pipe, extinguishing the pilot light. This commonly occurs in tightly sealed homes with powerful kitchen or bathroom exhaust fans. Opening a window slightly when using these fans can help alleviate the problem. If ventilation problems persist, consider having a professional evaluate whether your water heater installation meets current venting requirements.
Electric Water Heater Ignition Problems
Though electric water heaters don’t have pilot lights, they can still fail to heat water for various reasons. Troubleshooting these units involves checking electrical components rather than gas-related parts. Most electric water heater problems are related to power supply, heating elements, or thermostats.
Checking the Power Supply
First, verify that your electric water heater is receiving power. Check your home’s circuit breaker panel to ensure the breaker controlling the water heater hasn’t tripped. Even if the breaker appears to be in the “On” position, flip it fully off and then back on to reset it completely. Some water heaters have a separate disconnect switch near the unit that should also be checked.
If power is reaching the water heater but it still won’t heat, use a non-contact voltage tester to check for electrical current at the water heater’s junction box. Ensure all wire connections are tight and free of corrosion. Loose connections can cause intermittent heating problems or complete failure. Remember to turn off power at the breaker before inspecting any internal electrical components.
Testing the Heating Elements
Electric water heaters typically have two heating elements – an upper and lower element. When either fails, hot water production is reduced or eliminated. To test them, first shut off power to the water heater at the circuit breaker. Remove the access panels and insulation covering the elements. Disconnect the wires from the element terminals, labeling them to ensure proper reconnection.
Using a multimeter set to measure ohms (Ω), touch the probes to the two terminals on the heating element. A functioning element should show a reading between 10-30 ohms depending on its wattage. A reading of infinity or zero indicates a failed element requiring replacement. Elements can also fail due to sediment buildup, which causes them to overheat and burn out prematurely.
Thermostat Issues
Electric water heaters have thermostats that control when the heating elements activate. Most units have two thermostats, one for each element. Faulty thermostats can prevent the heating elements from turning on, even if the elements themselves are functional. Set the thermostat to its highest setting temporarily while testing to ensure it’s calling for heat.
To test a thermostat, turn off power to the water heater, remove the access panel and insulation, and use a multimeter to check for continuity. With the thermostat set to the highest temperature, it should allow current to flow through when the water is cooler than the set point. If testing confirms a faulty thermostat, replace it with an identical model designed for your specific water heater.
Reset Button Problems
Electric water heaters have a high-temperature cutoff switch (reset button) designed to prevent overheating. This button automatically trips when water temperatures get dangerously high, cutting power to the heating elements. The reset button is typically a red button located near the upper thermostat. Press the reset button firmly to see if this resolves the heating issue.
If the reset button trips repeatedly, this indicates an underlying problem such as a faulty thermostat, shorted heating element, or excessive sediment buildup causing overheating. Continually resetting the button without addressing the root cause can be dangerous. Multiple reset button trips warrant professional inspection to identify and resolve the underlying issue causing the overheating condition.
When to Call a Professional
While many water heater ignition problems can be resolved through DIY troubleshooting, some situations require professional expertise. Knowing when to call for help can prevent dangerous situations, costly damage, and unnecessary frustration. Safety concerns should always prompt an immediate call to a licensed plumber or HVAC technician.
Warning Signs of Serious Problems
Several indications suggest your water heater issue goes beyond simple DIY fixes. Unusual sounds like rumbling, popping, or banging often indicate severe sediment buildup or pressure problems. Water discoloration, particularly rusty water, suggests internal tank corrosion. Any smell of gas near your water heater requires immediate professional attention and possible evacuation of your home.
Leaking water around the base of your water heater typically indicates a tank failure, which requires complete replacement rather than repair. Visible corrosion on connections, valves, or the tank exterior also suggests advanced deterioration. If you notice significant temperature fluctuations or if the water never gets hot despite power/gas being available, complex control or sensor issues may be at play.
Gas Leak Safety
Gas leaks present serious health and safety hazards, including potential explosion or carbon monoxide poisoning. If you detect the distinctive rotten egg odor of natural gas around your water heater, exit your home immediately without touching any electrical switches, unplugging devices, or using phones inside the house. Once outside at a safe distance, call your gas utility’s emergency number or 911.
Never attempt to locate or repair a gas leak yourself. Other signs of potential gas problems include dead houseplants near the water heater, a hissing sound near gas connections, or bubbles forming when soapy water is applied to gas fittings. Even small gas leaks can create dangerous conditions, so professional inspection is essential whenever gas leakage is suspected.
Complex Control Valve Issues
Modern water heater control valves contain sophisticated electronics and precision components that require specialized knowledge to diagnose and repair. If your troubleshooting points to control valve problems, professional replacement is usually the most practical solution. Attempting to repair or replace these valves without proper training can lead to gas leaks, improper water temperature regulation, or complete system failure.
Signs of control valve problems include error codes on digital displays, pilot lights that light but don’t trigger main burner ignition, or water temperature that doesn’t correspond to thermostat settings. A professional can accurately diagnose whether the valve needs replacement or if another component is causing the control valve to malfunction, potentially saving you from unnecessary parts replacement.
How to Avoid Being Ripped Off and Get a Fair Water Heater Repair Price
Finding the right water heater repair expert can be tricky—some companies offer rock-bottom prices because they’re inexperienced or have poor reputations, while others charge far too much for the same work. That’s why the smartest way to get quality repairs at a fair price is to compare estimates from top-rated local pros. Meet with each, learn about their history and the experience of the technicians that will do the work. Choose an experienced water heater repair contractor with reasonable rates. You can expedite this process by using our Free Local Quotes service.
When you fill out a quick form and submit it, you’ll soon be contacted by three of the top water heater repair and installation companies near you. They are prescreened for experience, and all are licensed and insured for your protection. Click below to get started and protect your home and wallet today.
Preventive Maintenance to Avoid Future Ignition Problems
Regular maintenance significantly reduces the likelihood of water heater ignition failures and extends the lifespan of your unit. Most preventive measures are simple and inexpensive compared to emergency repairs or premature replacement. Establishing a consistent maintenance schedule is key to reliable hot water service.
Regular Inspection Schedule
Commit to inspecting your water heater at least twice yearly. Check for signs of wear, corrosion, or leakage around fittings, valves, and the tank base. Examine the pilot light on gas models to ensure it burns with a steady blue flame. Test the pressure relief valve by carefully lifting the lever and allowing a small amount of water to discharge, confirming the valve operates freely.
For electric models, listen for unusual sounds when the elements are heating and check that both upper and lower elements are functioning by running hot water until it cools, then monitoring how quickly it reheats. Inspect electrical connections for signs of corrosion or looseness. Record your maintenance activities, including dates and observations, to track any developing issues over time.
Cleaning Procedures
Sediment buildup is a leading cause of water heater problems. Every six months, flush a few gallons from the tank through the drain valve at the bottom of the unit. For more thorough cleaning, annual draining and flushing of the entire tank removes accumulated sediment that can insulate heating elements, cause overheating, or create noise.
For gas water heaters, gently clean the pilot assembly, thermocouple, and burner surfaces using compressed air or a soft brush to remove dust and debris. Avoid using chemical cleaners that might leave residues. For electric models, check whether your water heater manufacturer recommends periodic heating element cleaning with vinegar solutions to remove mineral scale that reduces heating efficiency.
Part Replacement Timelines
Some water heater components have predictable lifespans and can be proactively replaced before they fail. Thermocouples in gas water heaters typically last 3-5 years and are inexpensive to replace preventively. Anode rods, which protect your tank from corrosion, should be inspected annually and replaced when more than 50% deteriorated, usually every 3-5 years.
Heating elements in electric water heaters typically last 5-10 years depending on water quality and usage patterns. In areas with hard water, more frequent replacement may be necessary. Pressure relief valves should be replaced if they show any signs of leaking or failure to reset properly after testing, typically every 5 years. Following these timelines helps prevent the cascade of problems that can occur when one component fails and damages others.
