Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace affects energy bills, comfort, and carbon footprint for years. This guide compares heat pump vs furnace performance, costs, maintenance, and climate suitability, with clear examples and a simple break-even formula to help homeowners decide confidently.
How Each System Works
A heat pump moves heat rather than making it. In heating mode, it extracts heat from outdoor air and transfers it indoors. In cooling mode, it reverses to act like an air conditioner. Because it moves heat, it can deliver two to four units of heat energy per unit of electricity.
A gas furnace burns natural gas or propane. Combustion heats a heat exchanger, and a blower pushes hot air through ducts. Efficiency depends on the percentage of fuel energy converted to heat in the home. Electric furnaces use resistance coils and have near-100% efficiency, but much higher operating costs than heat pumps.
Efficiency Metrics Explained
Heat Pumps: SEER2, HSPF2, And COP
Cooling efficiency is rated by SEER2; higher SEER2 means lower summer electricity use. Heating efficiency is rated by HSPF2. A practical way to compare heating is the coefficient of performance (COP), which is useful for cost calculations. Seasonal COP commonly ranges from about 2.0 to 3.5 in typical U.S. climates.
Rule of thumb: HSPF2 of 9.5 roughly corresponds to a seasonal COP near 2.7–2.9, depending on climate and home load profile. Cold-climate models hold higher COP at low temperatures.
Furnaces: AFUE
Furnace efficiency is measured by AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency). A 95% AFUE furnace converts 95% of the fuel’s energy into useful heat. Most new condensing models range from 92% to 98% AFUE. Non-condensing 80% AFUE furnaces are still found in some homes but are less efficient and often restricted by local codes in colder regions.
Climate And Performance
Modern cold-climate heat pumps are engineered to deliver reliable heating in freezing weather. Many can operate down to -5°F to -13°F, maintaining a significant share of their rated capacity at 5°F. Performance varies by model, installer sizing, and building insulation.
In very cold climates or older homes with higher heat loss, a dual-fuel system (heat pump with gas furnace backup) or a heat pump with electric resistance backup can ensure comfort during extreme cold. In milder climates, a heat pump usually supplies all needed heat efficiently.
Comfort Differences
Heat pumps deliver steady, gentler heat with longer run times and supply air typically in the 90–110°F range. This reduces hot-cold swings and can improve humidity control in winter. Variable-speed (inverter) compressors adjust output to closely match the load.
Furnaces deliver hotter air, often 120–140°F, and cycle on and off. Some homeowners prefer the “toasty” feel, but short cycles can cause temperature swings and dry indoor air. High-end furnaces with modulating burners and variable-speed blowers provide more even comfort.
Don’t Overpay for HVAC Services – Call 888-894-0154 Now to Compare Local Quotes!
Costs: Equipment, Installation, And Maintenance
Installed costs vary by region, home, and complexity. Duct condition, electrical capacity, refrigerant line runs, and venting affect quotes. The ranges below reflect common U.S. scenarios.
| System | Typical Installed Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Pump (Ducted, Standard) | $8,000–$15,000 | Replaces AC and adds heating; variable-speed and cold-climate models cost more. |
| Cold-Climate Heat Pump | $10,000–$20,000 | Higher capacity at low temps; may need larger electrical circuits. |
| Ductless Mini-Split (Per Head) | $3,000–$6,000 | Useful for additions, zoned upgrades, or homes without ducts. |
| Gas Furnace (Replacement Only) | $3,500–$7,500 | Does not include AC replacement; venting and gas line add cost. |
| AC + Furnace (Full HVAC) | $9,000–$18,000 | Comparable to a single heat pump system covering both modes. |
Maintenance: Heat pumps and furnaces both need annual service and regular filter changes. Heat pumps also need coil cleaning and refrigerant checks. Furnaces need combustion safety checks and flue inspection. Costs are similar for routine service; major repairs vary by component and age.
Operating Costs: Electricity Vs Natural Gas
Operating cost depends on local electricity and gas prices, climate, equipment efficiency, and thermostat settings. National energy prices vary widely by state, so using local rates is essential for accurate comparisons.
Break-Even Cost Formula
To compare heating costs, calculate the cost to deliver the same heat (per 100,000 BTU, or “one therm” of delivered heat):
- Furnace cost per 100,000 BTU delivered ≈ ($/therm) ÷ AFUE
- Heat pump cost per 100,000 BTU delivered ≈ (29.3 ÷ COP) × ($/kWh)
Set them equal to find the break-even electricity price:
Break-even $/kWh ≈ [($/therm ÷ AFUE) × (COP ÷ 29.3)].
Example with $1.40/therm gas, 95% AFUE, and COP 2.8: Break-even ≈ (1.40 ÷ 0.95) × (2.8 ÷ 29.3) ≈ 0.144 $/kWh. If local electricity is lower, the heat pump is cheaper to run; if higher, the furnace wins.
Seasonal Example
Assume a home needs 50 million BTU of delivered heat per year.
- 95% AFUE furnace: Fuel required ≈ 50,000,000 ÷ 0.95 = 52,631,579 BTU ≈ 526 therms. At $1.20/therm: about $631. At $1.80/therm: about $947.
- Heat pump at seasonal COP 2.8: Electricity needed ≈ 50,000,000 ÷ (2.8 × 3,412) ≈ 5,233 kWh. At $0.13/kWh: about $680. At $0.20/kWh: about $1,047.
In milder climates (higher seasonal COP), heat pumps usually have a clear cost advantage. In very cold climates with higher electricity prices, high-efficiency furnaces may be cheaper unless using a top-tier cold-climate heat pump.
Summer Cooling Matters
A heat pump replaces both the furnace and AC. If an existing AC is old or inefficient, a new high-SEER2 heat pump can cut summer bills substantially, improving the overall annual economics of choosing a heat pump.
Reliability, Lifespan, And Noise
Typical lifespans vary by brand, installation quality, and maintenance. Furnaces often last 15–20 years. Conventional heat pumps commonly last 12–18 years, with many inverter-driven systems performing well beyond a decade when maintained properly.
Outdoor heat pump units make fan and compressor noise; placement matters. Furnaces are indoors and mainly produce blower noise. Variable-speed equipment in both categories tends to be quieter during most operation.
Safety And Health
Heat pumps do not burn fuel, so there is no risk of carbon monoxide from the unit. They also eliminate fuel storage and combustion byproducts. Proper electrical installation and refrigerant handling remain vital for safety and performance.
Gas furnaces require venting and combustion air. Risks include carbon monoxide if venting fails or heat exchangers crack, and gas leaks if piping or valves malfunction. Annual professional inspection and functional CO detectors on each floor are important safeguards.
Environmental Impact
Heat pumps reduce on-site emissions. Overall emissions depend on the local electricity mix. In many U.S. regions, grid carbon intensity has declined as wind, solar, nuclear, and gas replace coal, which improves the environmental case for heat pumps each year.
High-efficiency furnaces are cleaner than older models but still emit CO₂ at the home. For households aiming to reduce emissions, a heat pump—especially one powered by a green electricity plan—provides a large step toward decarbonization.
Incentives, Rebates, And Financing
Federal incentives under the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (Internal Revenue Code Section 25C) provide up to 30% of project cost with annual caps. Qualifying electric heat pumps may receive up to $2,000 per year in federal tax credits. Verify current efficiency criteria and tax guidance before purchase.
Some high-efficiency gas furnaces may qualify for up to $600 in federal credit if they meet specific criteria. There is also a separate credit for efficient blower motors. Availability and requirements change; check Energy Star and IRS resources or consult a tax professional.
States and utilities often offer additional rebates. Utility incentives for heat pumps commonly range from $300 to $2,000+. Programs targeting low- and moderate-income households can be more generous. Income-based electrification rebates authorized by federal law are rolling out state by state; check state energy offices for live programs.
Ducts, Electrical, And Installation Quality
System performance hinges on correct sizing and installation. A load calculation (Manual J), proper duct design (Manual D), and airflow verification (Manual T) can ensure quiet, efficient comfort. Oversizing—common with furnaces and legacy AC—can cause short cycling and uneven temperatures.
Don’t Overpay for HVAC Services – Call 888-894-0154 Now to Compare Local Quotes!
Heat pumps typically need a dedicated 240V circuit. Cold-climate models with electric resistance backup may require higher ampacity or load management. Homes with 100A service may need upgrades, though smart panels and load-shedding devices can sometimes avoid a full service replacement.
Dual-Fuel And Backup Heat Strategies
A dual-fuel system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. The heat pump handles moderate temperatures; the furnace takes over below a set balance point. This approach optimizes operating cost and comfort in cold climates without sacrificing AC efficiency.
Heat pumps can also use electric resistance backup strips to add capacity during extreme cold or defrost cycles. While strips are less efficient, they run only when needed if the primary unit is sized properly. Controls should minimize strip use to keep costs down.
New Construction Vs Replacement
In new homes, high-performance envelopes, right-sized ducts, and a heat pump can deliver excellent comfort and low operating costs. Builders can right-size electrical service and avoid gas piping and venting, simplifying construction.
In replacements, consider total system age. If the AC is near end-of-life, a heat pump can replace both systems at once, often at a similar total cost to a new furnace plus AC. If the AC is new, replacing only a failed furnace might be more economical short-term.
Comparative Snapshot: Heat Pump Vs Furnace
| Category | Heat Pump | Gas Furnace |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Function | Heats and cools | Heats only |
| Efficiency Metric | HSPF2 (heating), SEER2 (cooling), COP | AFUE |
| Operating Cost | Favors milder climates, competitive in many regions | Often lowest where gas is cheap and winters are severe |
| Cold-Weather Performance | Strong in modern cold-climate models | Consistent in all cold climates |
| Comfort Profile | Steady, even heat; excellent dehumidification in summer | Hotter supply air; potential cycling |
| Safety | No combustion or CO risk | Requires venting; CO risk if failures occur |
| Emissions | Depends on grid; zero on-site combustion | On-site CO₂ from combustion |
| Installed Cost | Similar to replacing furnace + AC | Lower if replacing furnace alone |
Dealing With Extreme Cold And Defrost Cycles
In freezing weather, outdoor coils accumulate frost. Heat pumps periodically reverse to melt frost, briefly pausing heating. Properly sized systems and smart controls minimize comfort impact. Cold-climate units use advanced refrigerants and compressors to maintain capacity and reduce defrost frequency.
Homes with high heat loss can add supplemental heat or improve insulation and air sealing. Building upgrades reduce peak loads, enabling smaller, quieter equipment and lower bills regardless of system type.
Indoor Air Quality And Humidity
Because heat pumps run longer at lower output, they can sustain better humidity control in cooling season. In heating season, fewer temperature spikes may reduce dryness. Filters and duct cleanliness matter for both systems.
Furnaces can be paired with humidifiers to counter winter dryness. Both systems can integrate high-MERV or electronic filters, ERVs/HRVs for fresh air, and UV or PCO devices when appropriate. Duct sealing helps keep dust and pollutants out.
Common Myths, Clarified
- “Heat pumps do not work below freezing.” Modern cold-climate models heat effectively well below 32°F, many to -13°F.
- “Furnaces are always cheaper to run.” It depends on local prices and equipment. In many regions, heat pumps win annually.
- “Electric equals expensive.” Electric resistance heat is costly; heat pumps are 2–4× more efficient than resistance heat.
- “Bigger is better.” Oversizing hurts comfort and efficiency. Correct sizing is essential for both types.
How To Choose: A Practical Framework
Use these steps to navigate heat pump vs furnace decisions confidently.
- Check local energy prices. Gather $/kWh and $/therm. Use the break-even formula to compare.
- Assess climate and home shell. Colder climates and drafty homes favor dual-fuel or upgrades.
- Evaluate existing AC. If it is old, a heat pump may be the most cost-effective full-system upgrade.
- Request a Manual J. Reject bids without a load calculation and airflow design.
- Verify electrical capacity. Plan circuits or load management for heat pumps.
- Seek incentives. Stack federal, state, and utility rebates where available.
- Prioritize installer quality. Look for certifications, references, and performance commissioning.
Worked Selection Examples
Example 1: Milder Climate (e.g., Atlanta)
Electricity: $0.14/kWh; Gas: $1.50/therm. Heat pump seasonal COP: 3.0; Furnace AFUE: 95%. Break-even ≈ (1.50 ÷ 0.95) × (3.0 ÷ 29.3) ≈ $0.162/kWh. Since $0.14 is below break-even, the heat pump likely costs less to run and also handles cooling efficiently.
Example 2: Cold Climate (e.g., Minneapolis)
Electricity: $0.16/kWh; Gas: $1.10/therm. Heat pump seasonal COP: 2.4 with cold-climate unit; Furnace AFUE: 96%. Break-even ≈ (1.10 ÷ 0.96) × (2.4 ÷ 29.3) ≈ $0.095/kWh. Since local electricity is higher, a furnace may be cheaper for cold snaps, but a dual-fuel heat pump can still reduce total annual cost and emissions.
Key Specs To Look For
- Heat pump: HSPF2 ≥ 8.1 (baseline), cold-climate certification for northern zones, SEER2 ≥ 15 for cooling efficiency, variable-speed compressor, low-ambient heating data, sound ratings, and thermostat compatibility.
- Furnace: AFUE ≥ 95%, sealed combustion, ECM blower motor, modulating or two-stage burner, proper venting materials, and robust safety controls.
Sizing And Distribution
Right-sizing depends on envelope quality and orientation, not only square footage. Manual J considers insulation, windows, infiltration, and internal gains. Manual D designs ducts for correct static pressure and room airflow. Commissioning should include measured static pressure and supply/return temperatures.
Zoning: Variable-speed heat pumps and modulating furnaces work best with zoning or thoughtful duct design to avoid short cycling. Ductless systems offer room-by-room zoning with high efficiency.
Total Cost Of Ownership
Total cost includes purchase price, installation, financing, incentives, maintenance, and energy over the system life. When replacing both furnace and AC, a single high-efficiency heat pump can be cost-competitive, especially with rebates and fuel savings.
Don’t Overpay for HVAC Services – Call 888-894-0154 Now to Compare Local Quotes!
In regions with very low gas prices and higher electric rates, a high-efficiency furnace paired with a modern AC or a dual-fuel configuration can minimize lifecycle cost while enhancing summer efficiency.
Resilience And Power Outages
Both furnaces and heat pumps require electricity to run blowers and controls. During outages, neither operates without backup power. A correctly sized generator or home battery with load management can support either system. Heat pumps without electric resistance backup have lower surge loads, helping with backup sizing.
Future-Proofing And Home Value
Heat pumps align with building codes and market trends moving toward higher efficiency and lower emissions. Buyers increasingly value efficient, all-electric HVAC with smart controls. Homes that can demonstrate low utility bills and comfort often see marketing advantages.
High-efficiency furnaces remain a solid choice where gas infrastructure is strong and electricity is costly. Systems with documented maintenance, right-sizing, and clear operating cost data give buyers greater confidence.
Quick FAQ
Do heat pumps work in snow? Yes, but outdoor units need clearance and proper mounting. Keep snow and ice away from coils and drains.
Will a heat pump increase my electric bill? Heating electricity use rises, but gas use drops to zero. Many households see lower total energy cost, especially when replacing an older AC.
Is an electric furnace the same as a heat pump? No. Electric furnaces use resistance heat and are far less efficient. Heat pumps move heat and usually cost much less to operate.
How often should systems be serviced? Annually. Change filters as recommended, typically every 1–3 months, or more often in dusty homes or with high-MERV filters.
Action Checklist
- Gather your last 12 months of utility bills to determine $/kWh and $/therm.
- Request quotes that include Manual J load, duct assessment, and commissioning steps.
- Ask for low-ambient performance data for heat pumps and full AFUE details for furnaces.
- Use the break-even formula to compare realistic operating costs.
- Stack incentives: federal, state, and utility. Confirm eligibility before signing a contract.
- Prioritize installer reputation and references over brand alone.
How to Get the Best HVAC Prices
- Firstly, keep in mind that installation quality is always the most important thing for residential HVAC project. So never sacrifice contractor quality for a lower price.
- Secondly, remember to look up the latest rebates as we talked above.
- Thirdly, ask for at least 3 bids before you make the decision. You can click here to get 3 free estimates from your local contractors, and this estimate already takes rebates and tax credit into consideration and filter unqualified contractors automatically.
Lastly, once you chose the right contractor, remember to use the tactics from this guide: Homeowners Tactics When Negotiating with HVAC Dealer to get the final best price.
