Thermostat Buying Guide: Compatibility Check & Popular Thermostat Reviews 2018

thermostat review

This thermostat buying guide provides information that will assist you in selecting a thermostat that properly controls the type of HVAC system you have and has the performance features you want. Many thermostats are also called controls, since they do more than simply sense temperature and turn the system on or off in response. Controls are designed to optimize indoor comfort, convenience and energy efficiency. Here’s where we’re going in this thermostat control buying guide:

  • Part 1 is about thermostat compatibility with your system
  • Part 2 is about the features you might want and whether they’re worth the extra expense
  • Part 3 is about the reviews for common HVAC brands and 3rd-party brands.

Let’s do this!

Part 1: Thermostat Basics and Your HVAC System

Each thermostat is designed to work with a specific system type. There are several areas in which compatibility must be ensured or the thermostat won’t work or won’t allow you to get the best performance from your heating and air conditioning.

Thermostat Voltage

HVAC systems can be categorized by the type of power they require:

  • 110V or 240V power: These are called high-voltage or line-voltage systems and include electric furnaces and electric baseboard systems.
  • 24V power: These are called low-voltage systems and include most split and package systems with gas or oil furnaces, air conditioners, heat pumps and boilers.
  • Millivolt power: These are gas-fired heaters that don’t use electricity because they don’t have a blower fan. Most are used for supplemental heat or space heating.

Each HVAC system type requires a thermostat compatible with the power it uses. As noted, most residential heating and air conditioning systems use 24V power, and these are the thermostats we discuss in the rest of this article. However, there are different categories of 24V thermostat, and the next section discusses matching your HVAC system to the right 24V thermostat.

Staged Heating and Cooling: What it Means for your Thermostat Purchase

For years, furnaces were manufactured with one operating mode. They were either on and running at full capacity or they were off. When central air conditioning was introduced, it was the same. This is known as single-stage heating and cooling, 100% capacity being the only stage. Today, single-stage furnaces, heat pumps and ACs are still produced, but there are two other performance tiers. Here are all three:

  • Single-stage systems, as defined above, are made by every HVAC brand.
  • Two-stage systems offer two stages of heating and cooling. First stage is usually about 65% capacity, and second-stage is 100% capacity. The units run on the first stage most of the time. The advantages of lower capacity include better efficiency, quieter performance and temperatures that are more balanced. When the house cools off or warms rapidly due to changing outdoor temperatures, the system might need to run on 100% capacity for a cycle to compensate. If you change the thermostat setting by several degrees, second-stage/full-capacity heating or cooling might also be required. Every brand makes two-stage furnaces, ACs and heat pumps.
  • Variable capacity systems operate at any percentage of capacity between about 40% and 100%. This ability takes the performance advantages of two-stage to the next level – the most efficient, quietest and most precise heating and cooling. Originally, only Carrier made variable-capacity equipment, which is also called modulating and variable-speed performance. Then, Lennox, Trane, Heil, Goodman, Armstrong and other major brands began producing it, though at this writing there are still a few that don’t.

The question is, how does staged heating and cooling affect thermostat choice? The answer is that thermostats are made in single-stage, two-stage and variable-capacity models too.

  • Single-stage thermostats: These models support single-stage operating. This means that they accommodate one wire for heating, usually labeled W or W1, and one wire for cooling, typically Y or Y1. Other wires accommodate different features such as 24V power, the fan or a common wire, briefly discussed later.
  • Two-stage thermostats: These units have terminals to accommodate two heating wires, W1 and W2, and two AC wires, Y1 and Y2, plus power, fan, common wire and possibly additional functions such as a reversing valve for a heat pump. The thermostat uses its temperature sensor to determine if first-stage heating or cooling is sufficient to maintain the desired indoor temperature or if the second stage is required. It sends the heating or cooling signal via the appropriate wire, for example Y1 or Y2.
  • Variable-capacity/Communicating thermostats: These units are a different breed of the thermostat. They are called communicating thermostats, and we’ve completed a guide called HVAC System: Communicating vs Non-communicating that spells out the differences. For our purposes, it’s enough here to say that single-stage and two-stage thermostats are non-communicating while thermostats that accommodate variable-capacity systems must be communicating.

Rather than having wires that give direct signals for first or second stage heating or cooling and wires for other performance features, communicating thermostats are built with just four wires: A single wire for heating, a single wire for cooling and two wires that provide power and allow the components and the thermostat to “communicate.” This means the components and temperature sensors send information to the thermostat, and the thermostat responds by controlling precisely how much heating or air conditioning is required to keep the home at the temperature desired with little variation.

How to Check Compatibility for Current HVAC System

When replacing a thermostat, the first step is to know what heating and cooling stages your HVAC system is equipped for. Once you do, you can select a suitable replacement.

Most non-communicating HVAC systems have up to 12 wires coming from the furnace or air handler to the location the thermostat is mounted. You can determine your system capabilities by checking what wires are connected to the thermostat. The others are probably coiled together. Check your system capabilities with these tips:

  • Remove the thermostat cover from the mounting bracket to expose the wires and wire terminals
  • W (white) is used for heating: If W (or W1) is the only W terminal with a wire connected, you have a single-stage furnace or heat pump
  • If W (or W1) and W2 are connected, you have a two-stage furnace or heat pump
  • Y (yellow) is used for cooling: If Y (or Y1) is the only Y terminal with a wire connected, you have a single-stage AC or heat pump
  • If Y (or Y1) and Y2 are connected, you have a two-stage AC or heat pump
  • Note: If you have a heat pump, then it will have just one W and one Y terminal connected or both W and Y terminals, not one W and two Y’s or vice-versa

There will be other wires connected, either some or all the following:

  • Red – 24V power
  • Green – Furnace or air handler fan (G wire)
  • Blue/Black – Common wire (C wire)
  • Orange – Reversing valve for heat pump air conditioning mode
  • Blue – Reversing valve for heat pump heating mode
  • Various color, labeled E – Emergency/backup electric heat in an air handler

C Wire Issue

90% thermostats (especially for WIFI thermostat) in the market need a C wire to get running. If you can not find C wire in your current system, no worries. Check our recent article: What If I don’t Have a Wire to find a proper way to get C wire back.

Do You Have a Communicating HVAC System?

If you open the thermostat and see only four wires, you might have a communicating thermostat. Common terminal connections are one each white, yellow, green and red. That can cause confusion, because the same four wire connections can also be a single-stage system.

These tips will assist you in determining whether a system with a four-wire thermostat is a single-stage or communicating system:

  • Currently, only manufacturers of furnaces, ACs and heat pumps make communicating thermostats, so if yours is a third-party brand like Honeywell, Emerson, White-Rodgers, GE, Ecobee, Lux, Geo or WiserAir, it is not a communicating thermostat, and your system is a single-stage system
  • If the thermostat is made by the same HVAC manufacturer as the furnace, then it should have one of these names:
  • Amana, Goodman and Daikin ComfortNet
  • Armstrong Air Comfort Sync
  • Bryant Evolution
  • Carrier Infinity
  • Coleman Echelon
  • Heil, Comfortmaker, Keep Rite and others Observer
  • Lennox iComfort
  • Luxaire Acclimate
  • Maytag, Tappan, Westinghouse, Nu-Tone or Broan iQ Drive
  • Rheem and Ruud Comfort Control System
  • Trane and American Standard ComfortLink II
  • York Affinity

Buying a Compatible Thermostat

Once you’ve determined the capabilities of your current system, the rest is easy. There are three ways to make sure the thermostat you buy is compatible with the performance of your heating and air conditioning system:

1). Review the thermostat packaging or product description online. It will say “Works with 1 Stage heat or cool” or “Works with 2 Stage or multi-stage heat or cool.” Thermostats that support two-stage heating and cooling can be used with single-stage equipment.

2). Use the compatibility checker on the manufacturer’s website, like this one for the ecobee thermostat. You’ll be shown a chart and asked to select the colors of the wires your current thermostat has connected to it. When you submit the information, the page will tell you whether its compatible and if you need anything additional. Note that if you have the four-wire single-stage heating and cooling setup, the compatibility checker won’t be able to determine whether it’s a single-state or communicating system. Ecobee’s site asks you to take a picture of the wiring on the thermostat and email it to Ecobee customer service for determination.

3). Buy a thermostat from a local dealer that sells and installs the brand of equipment you have.

Part 2: Extra Features: Are They Worth the Extra Money?

Single-stage thermostats start at less than $20; two-stage models start at about $50. The cheapest models are non-programmable with no extra features. Every time you want a change in temperature, you must manually adjust them. It’s the way thermostats have been used since their inception. However, thermostats with features add convenience and might help you reduce your heating and cooling costs. Here are the most common thermostat features with a discussion of their value.

Programmable Thermostats

Thermostat that you can program to adjust the temperature setting automatically at set times of day have been shown to reduce heating and cooling costs by 10% to 15% when consistently employed. Most programmable thermostats are 5-2 thermostats, one program for weekdays and one for weekends. You’ll also see 5-1-1 and 7-day thermostats as you shop. Most allow you to program up to four temperature settings throughout the day. For example, a typical heating schedule might reflect times you’re home and awake and times your sleeping or away:

  • 68 degrees from 10pm to 6am
  • 72 degrees from 6am to 7:30am
  • 65 degrees from 7:30am to 4:30pm
  • 72 degrees from 4:30pm to 10pm

Programmable thermostats are worth the extra cost. Because digital technology has become so affordable, programmable thermostat price starts just slightly higher than non-programmable models – about $20 for single-stage programmable thermostats and $70 for two-stage programmable thermostats. When you consider that data shows savings up to 15%, the extra cost for a programmable model might be recouped in the first month.

WiFi Thermostats / Smart Thermostats

WiFi (or Wi-Fi) thermostats are programmable, but there’s an added layer of convenience and potential cost savings. You can monitor and control the thermostat using a smartphone, tablet or computer and the thermostat app. Using our sample program above, let’s say you decide to go shopping or to dinner with friends after work, and you won’t be home until 9pm. You can use the Wi-Fi/smart technology to move the change from 65 degrees to 72 degrees from 4:30 to 8:30. That’s four hours of energy savings. If similar events occur a couple times per week, the savings can add up to $10-$25 per month.

WiFi or smart thermostats are worth the extra cost if you have a variable schedule. These units start at about $70 for cheap models, but dependable units cost $85 to $300 without additional features like a touchscreen display. If your schedule is very consistent, spending the extra for WiFi capability isn’t worth the money. If your schedule isn’t predictable, you might get your money’s worth from the WiFi capability. Some smart thermostats like the ecobee4 have geofencing. Download the app to your phone, and it will be tracked. When you and your phone leave your neighborhood, the HVAC system adjusts to an away setting; re-enter your neighborhood, and it adjusts to a home setting. You set your neighborhood boundaries to give the system time to heat your house in winter and cool it in summer, so you walk into a comfortable home every time.

Touch Screen Thermostats

These are the costliest thermostats available when WiFi-enabled. They’re programmable, and those with WiFi capabilities show current outside temperature and conditions and give you a forecast for the next four to seven days depending on the model. Simple touchscreen thermostats without WiFi start at less than $40, and most are programmable for that price. Two-stage and communicating models cost more. WiFi-enabled touchscreen models start at about $160.

Non-WiFi touchscreen thermostats are worth the money, since they cost little more than push-button models. WiFi touchscreen thermostats probably are not worth the money, since you’re mainly paying extra for weather information that is available on our phones, computers, TV and other sources.

Zone Thermostats

A zoned HVAC system is one that allows for independent climate control within two or more zones of your home. For example, you can send less heat to bedrooms and more heat to living areas during winter days or keep bedrooms cool for summer sleeping while allowing the heat to rise in living areas during summer nights. Zoned HVAC systems use a series of dampers in the ductwork to control the flow of heated and cooled air.

Zone thermostats are a necessity if you have a zoned HVAC system. The cost of adding zone control to a heating and air conditioning system starts at about $2,000 and can cost twice that or more. Zone thermostats start at about $115 but most cost $200+. The bigger question is whether a zoned HVAC system is worth the extra $2,000-plus. They can be, if you use the zoning wisely to lower energy consumption in rooms that aren’t being used and if you plan to live in the home with the zoned system for at least five years.

Part 3: Top Thermostat Brands Reviews

Here are HVAC brand’s thermostat reviews. If you current HVAC unit is the high-end model of one of blow brands, you would better choose the same brand’s thermostat. Using different brand’s thermostat may lose functions (like communicating features) for high-end models.

Here are third party brands reviews:

  • Top 5 Honeywell Thermostat Reviews (coming soon)
  • Nest Thermostat Reviews (coming soon)
  • Ecobee Thermostat Reviews (coming soon)
  • Emerson Sensi Wifi Thermostat Reviews (coming soon)
  • Lux Thermostat Reviews (coming soon)

Thank you for researching your next thermostat right here on PickHVAC! Once you select a thermostat, let our readers know what you bought, the price paid and how you like it. Share your HVAC Price and Submit a Review tabs can be used for those purposes. Your friends might also appreciate this information if you share the article via social media.

0 comments… add one

Leave a Comment

DMCA.com Protection Status